The below list only has completed sports points. The race at the top is a bit tighter if one includes basketball. You can see those numbers on the spreadsheet link.

1 Appalachian State 62.5
2 South Alabama 51.0
3 Arkansas State 48.0
4 Texas State 45.5
5 Texas-Arlington 39.0
6 Georgia State 36.5
7 Troy 29.5
8 Georgia Southern 29.0
9 Arkansas-Little Rock 27.0
10 Louisiana-Lafayette 23.5
11 Louisiana-Monroe 10.5
12 Hartwick (Associate) 6.0
13t Idaho (Associate) 5.0
13t New Mexico State (Associate) 5.0
15 New Jersey Inst of Tech (Associate) 2.0
16 Howard (Associate) 1.0