http://herosports.com/news/the-best-col ... f-division

Scores are based on the following criteria:

Winning Percentage (since 2010) x 10
Each Conference Championship (Since 2000): 0.5 points
National Championships (Since 1960): 1 point
MVP Awards (Heisman/Payton/Hill/Gagliardi): 1 point
AFCA Coach of the Year Awards: 1 point

To avoid the clickbait, if you wish to cut to the chase:
http://herosports.com/news/the-best-col ... ivision#33