Kirk Herbsmoke and his Herbie Award picks for 2018

[CornCobPipes]

Herbsmoke picks Penn State QB - Trace McSorley to win the HEISMAN! What say you?

[AppSt94]

If they go undefeated then why not? The dude is a gamer.

[McLeansvilleAppFan]

Beating a quality opponent such as App State should build his Heisman résumé . Of course, that is not guaranteed.

[appchicago]

McSorley was mentioned as a dark horse Heisman pick last year, even with Saquon soaking up most of the spotlight. I think he's a reasonable pick for this year if the season breaks PSU's way.

[biggie]

Don't have high hopes and don't mind if he has a great season after our game, but would love to see him have 3-4 INTs for our game.

[ASU3432Mi]

Don't forget what we did to UGAs starting QB last year. Then their backup takes them to National Championship game.

[ericsaid]

Don't forget what we did to UGAs starting QB last year. Then their backup takes them to National Championship game.

McSorley is like Taylor but with a stronger arm and a bit more fluid athletically.

[appfanz]

On the flip side Dennis Dodd didn’t even have him in his top ten QB’s list this year.