The number was in relation to the only tie-in outside the Sun Belt that all parties involved and vested could make an argument for, other than the ACC and AAC, the Belk Bowl. Obviously it isn't going to happen but it's just for making an argument.Yosef84 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2019 3:28 pmYou say that with a lot of authority, but why wouldn't the CUSA choose New Orleans? One of the most likely conference championship games for CUSA at this point is La. Tech vs. Marshall. Southern Miss is also in the mix as well as FAI. Pretty sure La Tech recruits New Orleans area, as does Southern Miss. Marshall doesn't have lots of "local" bowls to choose from and frankly I think they'd love to play us. FAI might choose to go elsewhere closer to home. I think there is a significant chance we could get the champ.ericsaid wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2019 1:54 pmApp, if they are in NOLA, aren't going to get a game against the C-USA Champion though. The Champion will likely try to take a bowl in an area they recruit and where the match-up is against a high visibility opponent. If they get a game against a 7-5 P5 team instead of App, they will take it. That leaves App with number 2 or number 3.Yosef84 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:50 amThat's a matter of personal preference, but playing a 6-6 SEC/ACC team as our season finale isn't all that intriguing. We already have 2 P5 wins. A game against a CUSA (peer) champion would provide bragging rights for App and the SBC.
Sure, we all love to win games against the P5 but I refuse to buy into the narrative that ANY P5 game is better than a game against the G5, even if that G5 team is a quality "peer" of ours.
Would you rather play the number 3 C-USA team or number 5 ACC team? New Orleans may be a fine destination but the turnout for a game in Charlotte would be much higher and another win over a 5th place ACC team would provide more credence to App's progress from a national perspective than a win over FAU.
Also, what makes you think we would get the #5 position from any P5 tie-in? My guess is that we would wind up lower in the pecking order but I'd love to hear your support for that number. To answer your question, I would be disappointed with playing the #3 CUSA team so I would rather play the #5 ACC, but that isn't the scenario I was discussing and isn't a likely one (my opinion).
If you look at the C-USA bowl tie-ins, they get a P5 team and an AAC program. Depending on who the likely opponent is in either one of those bowls, and location, do you not believe that the first two programs would take a good long look at it to see who they would match-up with and the potential exposure that could provide? UAB chose the Boca Raton Bowl last season and i'm not sure if it was because of the AAC tie-in and they believed that they would play someone other than Northern Illinois or it had more to do with recruiting.
You have the Gasparilla Bowl in Tampa against an AAC team. Then you have the Independence Bowl against an ACC team (likely Florida State). Depending on the Frisco Bowl tie in this year, Louisiana Tech could choose to go there due to their proximity to Texas.
If Louisiana Tech wins the conference, I could see them going to New Orleans but like Louisiana, i'm sure that they may go elsewhere considering they have the first pick. I couldn't see Marshall choosing New Orleans though App might make that an interesting choice considering the future scheduling and history.
FAU or Marshall would be ideal for different reasons if you have no other choice. Southern Miss doesn't move the needle much and despite Louisiana Tech's success and the bowl atmosphere that playing an in-state team would provide, neither do they. From a football player perspective i'm sure it doesn't matter who the opponent is because they have 5-0 on the line.