appgrad95&97 wrote: ↑Wed Sep 27, 2023 1:23 pm
BambooRdApp wrote: ↑Wed Sep 27, 2023 12:57 pm
appgrad95&97 wrote: ↑Wed Sep 27, 2023 12:09 pm
kornegaylw wrote: ↑Wed Sep 27, 2023 11:08 am
311neers wrote: ↑Wed Sep 27, 2023 10:09 am
Think he meant leading the way in terms of wins and winning the SBC. All that you listed above is great, but that will die off if we continue to put out 6-6 and 7-5 seasons. Winning is the top of the chain, those you listed don't come if we go 6-6 every year or 7-5. At the moment, we are lagging behind JMU, Marshall, Troy, (ULL and Coastal and argument too) but we aren't far behind them and can jump them sooner than most thought. We've got a great opportunity and a good enough team to jump back into the race.
I don't have the time to look up the stats but since joining the Sun Belt I would bet we have the highest winning percentage for conference games and we have 4 conference titles. In that time period the next closest is 3 way tie with Troy, ArkSt & UL with 2. So he is still wrong.
Wining breads the stats above and in turn the stats above bread winning.
This is what I think divides us. Some think last year was a one off and well be back to competing for conference titles this year. We're obviously not going to win the SB every year but we should be in the mix. Others believe that last year was part of a trend. We went 3-5 in conference (and that took a miracle).
Actually there is a 3rd group. A group that we thought we would be decent last year..but would be mediocre this year due to changes in coach in for 3 straight years impacting recruiting and thinking we would be back to App St levels in 2024.
Well 3 injuries to our 3 best defensive players last year changed expectations mid season.
I am and have been for last 3 years thought this year would be the medicore year ..and it may still be.... however our defense, thus far has impressed me thus far..still have much season to go.
That's very fair. But we were below average last year. 4-6 against FBS opponents. Injuries happen. They hurt every team. I am terrified about what will happen if Nate gets hurt.
Now I get we are not Alabama, but they worked through as many coaching changes as anyone (obviously, not head coach, but coordinators).
Is the problem (if there is one) recruiting or player development? That's an honest question.
The best way to answer your question about recruiting or development is just to look at our current 2 deep chart. Look to see how many 5th-6th (covid) year juniors and seniors there are in that group that are App recruits and not transfer portal additions. The recruiting classes prior to Clark taking over are what should be our older seasoned players and we are very much lacking in those numbers. So on that front it was a recruiting miss for those years (albeit some really good players like Nate are in the small group). Now we have a lot of 3rd year sophomores and younger kids that are playing meaningful minutes and I would say those were recruiting hits and proof of good development.
It is just a fact that with coaching turnover it is often difficult to keep recruits, and I am not just talking about the head coach I am including coordinators and position coaches. I would argue that we have had more coaching turnover than any of our Sun Belt brethren and perhaps any G5 team. We haven't had the same offensive coordinator in back to back years since Satt was our coach and we often change position coaches for various reasons. Kids that are recruited by one coach often fall to the wayside when another coach comes on board and perhaps values different traits/styles of play than the previous coach that recruited them. I am not making excuses here, just pointing to facts.
All that being said, we seem to have righted the ship from last year. Our defense is vastly improved and our offense can move the ball on anyone at times. Last year sucked, no question about it. And if we don't turn this year around it will suck too (and Clark will be gone). I just happen to believe that the worst times are behind us and we are back on a positive trajectory. We have the coaches we want in place, our recruits are being developed and the players all seem to buy in. I still find it very telling that despite the terrible year we had last year, none of our key players departed via the transfer portal (Jalen is an exception bc for 200k anyone would leave) despite many on here that claimed there would be a mass exodus. That shows they all still have faith in our coaching staff, perhaps more of our fans should have the same faith as the players.